Craving something sweet to beat the summer heat? We’ve got you covered! Whether you’re a local or just visiting, central Indiana boasts some of the best ice cream spots that are sure to satisfy your taste buds. From classic flavors to unique creations, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
Dive into our curated list of the top 28 ice cream destinations in central Indiana. Plus, we’re sharing some personal favorites from the Yosha Snyder Group that you won’t want to miss.
BRICS
Located at 901 E. 64th Street on the Monon Trail, this shop has become the go-to in Broad Ripple for ice cream. With a wide range of offerings, there is something for everyone, including those with dairy and nut sensitivities.
Handels
A staple in the Indianapolis area since 1945, known for its generous portions and rich, creamy ice cream with a wide selection of flavors that rotate daily. Visit one of their locations in Carmel, Greenwood, Noblesville or Fishers.
LICK Ice Cream
With two locations, SoBro at 1049 E 54th Street and downtown at 906 Carrollton Avenue in The Garage at Bottleworks, LICK uses an artisanal approach to ice cream in small-batch flavors that highlight seasonal freshness.
Traders Point Creamery
The TPC farm on 9101 Moore Road in Zionsville is a destination as the working farm has both a farm store and a restaurant. Their ice cream is both 100% organic (the ingredients come from grass-fed cows) and made fully on site. They have classic and seasonal flavor dairy offerings.
Nicey
A fun alternative to traditional ice cream, Nicey has two locations: 833 E Westfield Blvd. in Broad Ripple and 11547 Yard Street at The Yard in Fishers. They offer all-natural ice pops and ice cream pies.
Dolce Vita
Craving Italian gelato? Dolce Vita, located at 4825 West 96th Street in Fishers, is a haven of authentic flavors of both gelato and ice. Dolce Vita offers gelato that is smooth, creamy, and bursting with flavor. From artisanal gelato to nostalgic ice cream parlors, Indianapolis’ local ice cream scene caters to every palate, making it a destination where Scoops of Joy await around every corner. Whether you’re exploring new flavors or enjoying timeless classics, these local hot spots promise a memorable ice cream experience during your summer adventures.